Black Dahlia Part 3: Seven Years Later, I Read the Black Dahlia Case Again
In Part 3 of the Black Dahlia deep dive, Heather finishes the forensic analysis of her original 2019 psychic reading and follows several unexpected threads that emerged during the research.
This episode digs into Elizabeth Short’s Hollywood circle, including Anne Toth, Mark Hansen, Maurice Clement, Dr. Patrick O’Reilly, and the explosive Brenda Allen scandal that exposed corruption inside the LAPD. As those connections begin overlapping, the reading starts looking less like a story about one mysterious killer and more like a glimpse into the complicated social world surrounding Elizabeth before her death.
Spotify 
Apple Podcasts 
RSS Feed In the final installment of our three-part Black Dahlia deep dive, we move beyond the familiar suspects and into the complicated web of people surrounding Elizabeth Short in the months before her murder.
Part 3 follows several names and connections that emerged while Heather was conducting a forensic review of her original 2019 psychic reading. That trail leads through Elizabeth’s Hollywood social circle and into a world populated by nightclub owners, doctors, questionable associates, organized vice, and an LAPD already struggling with serious allegations of corruption.
Among the people examined are Anne Toth, Mark Hansen, Maurice Clement, and Dr. Patrick O’Reilly, along with the explosive Brenda Allen scandal and what it reveals about prostitution, protection, and corruption in 1940s Los Angeles.
And that context matters.
Because one of the strongest themes running through Heather’s original reading was that Elizabeth’s murder may not have happened in isolation. The reading repeatedly suggested multiple people, a man Elizabeth knew and trusted, the presence or involvement of another woman, and the possibility that people surrounding the crime knew considerably more than they ever admitted.
But this series was never supposed to be an exercise in proving a psychic reading correct.
Heather continues the forensic audit of the 2019 session by identifying the misses, examining information she could have encountered before the reading, and separating possible psychic impressions from details that may have been influenced by the enormous mythology surrounding the Black Dahlia case.
Then, seven years after the original session, Heather reads the case again.
With years of distance, significantly more historical research, and a very different understanding of Elizabeth Short’s world, she conducts a new tarot reading to see whether the story changes.
Instead, several familiar themes return.
A romantic or trusted male connection. More than one person surrounding what happened. A woman whose role may have been more important than it first appears. And once again, the unsettling possibility that the person responsible for Elizabeth’s death may not have been the same person responsible for the mutilation and disposal of her body.
Nearly 80 years after Elizabeth Short was murdered, her case remains officially unsolved. Part 3 doesn't pretend to solve it.
Instead, we finish where this investigation was always meant to go: separating history from mythology, psychic perception from contamination, and asking whether some of the strangest details from a reading conducted in 2019 deserve another look.
What You’ll Hear
-
The final forensic analysis of Heather’s 2019 Black Dahlia psychic reading
-
Elizabeth Short’s Hollywood social circle and the people surrounding her before her death
-
Anne Toth, Mark Hansen, Maurice Clement, and Dr. Patrick O’Reilly
-
The Brenda Allen scandal and corruption within the LAPD
-
The complicated overlap between Hollywood, vice, powerful men, and law enforcement in 1940s Los Angeles
-
Why the original reading continued to suggest more than one person was involved
-
The recurring appearance of another woman in the psychic material
-
Which elements of the 2019 reading did not survive the historical fact-check
-
Psychic contamination and the difficulty of separating genuine impressions from previously encountered information
-
Heather’s new tarot reading of the Black Dahlia case seven years later
-
The surprising themes that appear in both the 2019 and 2026 readings
-
The possibility that Elizabeth’s killer and the person responsible for the mutilation and disposal of her body were not the same person
-
Where the evidence, history, and psychic material leave the case at the end of this three-part investigation
Black Dahlia Deep Dive Part 3 concludes our three-part investigation into the murder of Elizabeth Short, the people surrounding her, and what happens when a years-old psychic reading is finally put up against the historical record.
Mentions in this Episode:
Mark Hansen – Grin and Bare It – The Black Dahlia Murder Case
"Black Dahlia" by William J. Mann: Does the 2026 Book Finally Solve It? | LACoroner.com
Deconstructing Dahlia (TV Series) - IMDb
Deconstructing the “Deconstructing Dahlia” project:
Black Dahlia Case May Have Major Break After Bloodstain Found in Old LA Motel
George Hodel: The Prime Suspect In The Black Dahlia Murder
🛸 Love what you heard? Keep following the weird.
Get full show notes, exclusive content, and the occasional paranormal rant at NVusAlien.com.
🔮 Want the universe to spill its secrets?
Book a tarot reading with Heather and pull the receipts straight from the void: Tarot Readings
📢 Tell your weird friends
Seriously. This podcast grows by word-of-mouth. Share it with your favorite conspiracy theorist, ghost hunter, or lowkey witchy cousin.